Few books seem as broadly misunderstood as George Orwell’s 1945 novel Animal Farm. This might seem surprising, because, as a parody children’s fable, the book is quite short and straightforward.
During the Cold War, the CIA famously wielded the book as a cudgel in the soft-power battle of propaganda. They intentionally facilitated the 1950 film adaptation, which among other things, completely changed the ending of the story. In American schools, Animal Farm has been predominantly taught as an anti-communist story— in other words, as a story in favor of the capitalist status quo.
However, especially now that I have re-read Animal Farm for a fourth time, I find this interpretation extremely dishonest.
People often claim that Animal Farm is about how communism necessarily leads to oppression, implying that capitalism is the moral alternative— which completely ignores that in the story, the oppression the pigs brought was, explicitly, the same oppression under which the animals suffered at the beginning of the story: capitalism.
This is why I think it’s extremely important to read Animal Farm with the context of Orwell’s real-life political views. Orwell was not a right-winger. He was not pro-capitalist. He wrote Animal Farm specifically about the USSR under Stalin, which he saw as a wrong turn in the fight for a more just society. He certainly was not trying to say that capitalism is a good system— quite the opposite.
In Orwell’s allegory, communism is represented by the animals’ revolutionary ideology of Animalism. Never in the book is Animalism itself condemned; in fact, it’s described very favorably.
The tragedy of Animal Farm is that the pigs recreated the exploitative system of capitalism, not that they implemented communism. The bleakness of the ending is because they abandoned Animalism and all it stood for, returning to the same oppressive farming system that the Revolution had sought to overturn.
The ending scene of the novel borders on the heavy-handed in making this point.
The Pigs Recreate Capitalism
Orwell is not subtle at all about the message that the pigs abandoned communism.
Even his choice of animal says something here. It’s speciesist, yes, but the cultural association is there— the insult is “capitalist pig”, not “communist pig.”
At the end of Animal Farm, the pigs host the human owners of the neighboring farms for a gathering at Animal Farm. At this gathering, Napoleon reassures the humans that there is no reason for mistrust between them. He states that:
- the pigs and the humans have the same interests
- there is nothing revolutionary about Animal Farm
- the “lower animals” on Animal Farm “did more work and received less food than any animals in the county.”
- the pigs wish to sustain “normal business relations with their neighbors
“He too, [Napoleon] said, was happy that the period of misunderstanding was at an end. For a long time there had been rumors— circulated, he had reason to think, by some malignant enemy— that there was something subversive and even revolutionary in the outlook of himself and his colleagues. They had been credited with attempting to stir up rebellion among the animals on neighboring farms. Nothing could be further from the truth! Their sole wish, now and in the past, was to live at peace and in normal business relations with their neighbors. This farm which he had the honor to control, he added, was a co-operative enterprise. The title-deeds, which were in his own possession, were owned by the pigs jointly.”
Napoleon subsequently announces that the animals will no longer refer to each other as “comrade”.
He says that the “strange custom” of marching past a boar’s skull on Sundays will be abolished too; in fact, he claims to not even know where this tradition originated. (However, the reader knows that this is the skull of Old Major, who represents Marx)
Napoleon further assures the humans that the farm will be getting a new flag, one which no longer has the hoof and horn symbol (representing, of course, the hammer and sickle)
And in case things still weren’t clear, Napoleon finally announces that the farm will no longer be called Animal Farm at all. He is restoring the farm to its “proper name”, The Manor Farm.
Compare this to Old Major’s speech at the beginning of the novel, in which he says, among other things:
“Never listen when they tell you that Man and the animals have a common interest.”
and
“In fighting against Man, we must not come to resemble him”
In this vein, there is the famous last line of the novel:
“The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which.”
Knowing that the humans in Animal Farm represent capitalists, symbolism doesn’t get much more in-your-face than this.
The most anti-communist reading of this book that would still be honest that I can think of is the interpretation that the story demonstrates an inherent impracticality of implementing communism (the classic “human nature” claim). Perhaps, one might argue, the story represents the inevitability of inequality and bad actors engineering the system to their own benefit, despite attempts at egalitarianism.
But that still doesn’t make the book supportive of capitalism, whose injustice it skewers from the first chapter. Even under this interpretation, it’s still impossible to read Animal Farm and believe that it supports the capitalist status quo.
For more Animal Farm analysis, see my post: Animal Farm Historical Allegory Explained: Summary and Analysis

1 comments on “Animal Farm Was Never Anti-Communist”